Complete Whispers in the Well Price Guide: Winners, Losers, and Everything Between

Release Date: November 7, 2025 (Prerelease) | November 14, 2025 (Worldwide)

Whispers in the Well brought us Gargoyles, The Black Cauldron, and a mystery-noir aesthetic unlike anything we'd seen in Lorcana before. Now that the dust has settled three months post-release, we can finally answer the question everyone's been asking: which cards held their value, and which ones crashed harder than the Headless Horseman's pumpkin?

Using verified market data spanning November 2025 through February 2026, we've tracked every chase card's price journey. No speculation, no guesswork—just cold, hard numbers about what actually sold and for how much.

The Big Picture: How the Set Performed

Whispers in the Well told two very different stories depending on which cards you pulled. The set featured the usual structure—2 Iconics, 18 Enchanteds, and 12 Legendaries—but the price spread was dramatic.

The Top-End: Strong. The best cards in this set held remarkably well compared to typical new set depreciation. If you hit a top-5 Enchanted or either Iconic, you made out like a bandit.

The Middle: Rough. Most Enchanteds dropped 35-45% from their week-one peaks, which is actually pretty standard but still painful if you bought in during the hype.

The Bottom: Brutal. Budget legendaries got absolutely decimated, with several cards losing 70%+ of their value.

But let's dig into the specifics, because the details tell a much more interesting story.

The Iconics: Tale of Two Villains

Ariel - Ethereal Voice (#241)
Current: $420 | Launch: $601 | Change: -30%

The first-ever Iconic Princess, and she commanded a premium for it. Ariel debuted around $600 during prerelease week and settled into the low $400s by February. That's actually impressive retention for an Iconic—these ultra-rare pulls usually see steeper drops as the "I MUST HAVE IT NOW" collectors get their copies.

The "Whisper" variant with its haunting noir aesthetic made this feel like a whole different character from previous Ariel prints. Combine that with being only the fourth Iconic ever printed, and you've got staying power.

Hades - Looking for a Deal (#242)
Current: $417 | Launch: $715 | Change: -42%

The first Iconic villain in Lorcana's history opened north of $700 and has slowly bled value down to the low $400s. Hades' effect is legitimately strong—forcing opponents to either feed you their best character or let you draw cards is exactly the kind of "damned if you do, damned if you don't" design that fits the Lord of the Underworld.

But here's the thing: Hades as a Legendary in the same set sells for $20. That's a 20x multiplier just for the Iconic treatment. At that point, you're paying for rarity and art, not playability. The competitive players grabbed their Legendary playset and moved on.

Verdict: Both Iconics are hovering right around $420, down 30-40% from launch. If you're buying for collection, that's actually not bad—they've stabilized. If you bought week one to flip? Ouch.

The Enchanted Elite: $200+ Club

Only two cards broke the $200 barrier, and they both earned it.

Cinderella - Dream Come True (#236)

Current: $217 | Launch: $341 | Change: -36%

The undisputed queen of Whispers in the Well. Cinderella isn't just expensive because she's a Princess (though that helps)—she's expensive because she's disgustingly good.

At the end of each turn, if you have a Princess character (including herself), you draw a card and gain an ink. In a format where card draw is king, Cinderella is basically an engine that pays for itself while building your board. The Legendary version ($35) is one of the most-played cards in the format for good reason.

The Enchanted dropped from $341 to $217, but considering how hard most enchanteds crashed, a 36% decline is honestly mild. This card has staying power because it has legitimate tournament demand backing up the collector premium.

Demona - Scourge of the Wyvern Clan (#227)

Current: $150 | Launch: $250 | Change: -40%

The Gargoyles hype was REAL. Demona opened around $250 and has slowly settled toward $150 as supply caught up with demand. But here's what's interesting: this card has more verified transactions than any other Enchanted in the set.

Why? She's playable. A 5/6 body that quests for 2 lore and forces opponents to exert characters is exactly what Amethyst decks want. The Legendary version ($29) is showing up in tournament lists, which means competitive players need copies, which means the Enchanted version has cross-demographic appeal.

If Gargoyles remain meta-relevant in future sets, don't be surprised if Demona creeps back up. The cult fanbase for this franchise is no joke.

The $100-$150 Tier: Solid but Declining

Spooky Sight (#237) - $139
The board wipe Sapphire desperately needed, wrapped in gorgeous Halloween artwork featuring Mickey, Donald, and Goofy as ghosts. Opened around $229, now at $139. Playable board wipes always have a floor, but this one's a bit situational, which explains the 39% drop.

Goliath - Clan Leader (#238) - $114
The second Gargoyles Enchanted sits at $114, down from $187. Goliath fixes the "Stone By Day" drawback that hamstrings Gargoyle decks, making him essential for that archetype. If Gargoyles get more support in future sets, expect this to firm up.

The $80-$100 Tier: Crossover Appeal

Can't Hold It Back Anymore (#228) - $93
The Elsa song everyone knows. Opened at $177, now at $93—a brutal 47% drop, the WORST decline among all Enchanteds. Turns out IP nostalgia can only carry a card so far when it doesn't slot into competitive decks. Elsa fans will always want it, but there aren't enough of them to support $180 pricing.

Webby Vanderquack - Junior Prospector (#229) - $88
DuckTales fans rejoiced, but at -45%, this card got walloped. Webby's effect is actually good (ramp + quest for 2), but she's in Emerald, which hasn't been the dominant ink lately. Meta shifts could change this story fast.

Simba - King in the Making (#224) - $81
The ONLY Enchanted that actually GAINED value post-launch. Opened around $79 and has crept up to $81. Why? Simba's cheap, playable, and Lion King is evergreen IP. Sometimes boring is beautiful.

The $70-$80 Tier: Playable but Niche

Malicious, Mean, and Scary (#231) - $76
The Tangled villain song dropped 45% from $138 to $76. Great art, decent effect, but too narrow for the current meta.

Judy Hopps - Lead Detective (#235) - $72
Zootopia's rabbit detective held up better than expected, down only 17% from $87. Detective synergies are real, and Sapphire/Steel is still a strong pairing. Might be undervalued at current price.

The $50-$70 Tier: The Budget Bling

The Black Cauldron (#230) - $60
This item has the HIGHEST transaction volume of any Enchanted in the set, yet it's only $60. Why? Because it's essential for reanimator strategies but doesn't have the name recognition to command collector premium. This is actually UP from launch—a true sleeper hit. Only lost 15%.

The Horned King - Wicked Ruler (#226) - $54
Black Cauldron got its villain, and the market said "meh." The Horned King is a Super Rare in the base set (not even legendary), so the Enchanted doesn't have the same pull. Down to $54, this is pure collector bait for cult IP fans.

Next Stop, Olympus (#232) - $54
Hercules action card with ready-and-rechallenge shenanigans. Fringe playable but not format-defining. Holds $54 on playability alone.

The $40-$50 Tier: Fighting for Relevance

Nick Wilde - Persistent Investigator (#239) - $48
Zootopia's sly fox sits at $48, down from $62. Detective synergy keeps him relevant, but he's competing in a crowded space.

Lady Tremaine - Sinister Socialite (#233) - $42
Cinderella's evil stepmother at $42. Down from... actually, we don't have launch data for this one, but safe to say she's not matching her stepdaughter's success.

Goofy - Galumphing Gumshoe (#223) - $40
Goofy in full detective mode. Playable, beloved character, but at $40, the market is saying "good, not great."

The Sword of Hercules (#240) - $39
Hercules' signature weapon at $39. Item cards have historically struggled in Lorcana outside of format staples, and this is no exception.

Baloo - Carefree Bear (#230) - $38
The Jungle Book bear bringing up the rear at $38. Baloo's chill vibes apparently don't translate to high market value.

The Legendaries: Where the Real Game Happens

While Enchanteds get all the attention, Legendary cards are where the REAL market signal lives. These cards have 10-20x the transaction volume of Enchanteds because they're actually obtainable (1 per 6 packs vs 1 per 96 packs). When a Legendary has massive volume AND holds value, you know it's meta-defining.

The Elite ($30+)

Cinderella - Dream Come True - $35
Over 2,000 transactions. TWENTY TIMES more than the Enchanted version. This card is tournament-staple tier. At $35, it's expensive for a Legendary, but players are paying it because the effect is that good.

Demona - Scourge - $29
Also over 2,000 transactions. The most-traded Legendary in the set. Amethyst/Steel decks need her, and the price reflects it.

Hades - Looking for a Deal - $20
Despite having a $417 Iconic version in the same set, the Legendary at $20 has just as much transaction volume. Why buy the Iconic when this does the same thing?

The Competitive Core ($10-$30)

Goliath - Clan Leader - $14
Nearly 2,000 transactions. Gargoyles need this, period.

The Headless Horseman - Terror of Sleepy Hollow - $11
Here's something WILD: This is the ONLY card in the entire set—Legendary or Enchanted—that GAINED value. Opened around $9, now at $11. Why? The market took a few weeks to realize just how strong "banish everything with 2 strength or less" really is. He's now showing up in Ruby aggro as a board-control finisher. Sometimes the meta takes a minute to catch on.

The Playables ($5-$10)

Webby Vanderquack - Junior Prospector - $7
Rapunzel - Ready for Adventure - $6

Both see tournament play, both have 1,700-1,900 transactions. These are the "I need a playset but won't break the bank" cards.

The Budget Bin (Under $5)

Hercules - Mighty Leader - $3.50
Shere Khan - Fearsome Tiger - $3.40
Daisy Duck - Paranormal Investigator - $3.40
The Black Cauldron - $2.10
Prince Eric - Protector of the Realm - $1.12

These cards have sub-500 transaction volume (except Cauldron). The market has spoken: collection only.

What the Numbers Tell Us

After tracking every card for three months, a few clear patterns emerged:

1. Playability trumps rarity
The Headless Horseman Legendary (+23%) outperformed most Enchanteds because tournaments discovered he's actually broken. Meanwhile, "Can't Hold It Back Anymore" Enchanted crashed 47% despite being THE Elsa song.

2. Transaction volume predicts staying power
Cinderella and Demona have 20x the transaction volume of most Enchanteds because players need them. High volume = sustained demand = price floor.

3. IP premium is real but limited
Gargoyles debuted with massive hype, and both Demona and Goliath held value better than similar cards. But The Horned King crashed because The Black Cauldron is too cult to support premium pricing. Disney Princesses remain the safest bet.

4. The 30-40% drop is inevitable
Almost every chase card lost 30-50% from week-one highs to month-three lows. That's just the nature of sealed product flooding the market. The cards that "only" lost 30% are the winners.

5. Week 2-3 is the buying window
Prices peaked during prerelease week, crashed hard in weeks 2-3 as boxes got cracked en masse, then stabilized by week 4-5. If you're buying singles, wait for the supply shock.

Investment Tiers

If we had to categorize the Whispers in the Well chase cards by their three-month performance:

WINNERS (Lost <30% or gained value):

• The Headless Horseman Legendary (+23%)

• The Black Cauldron Enchanted (-15%)

• Simba Enchanted (-2%)

• Judy Hopps Enchanted (-17%)

HELD GROUND (Lost 30-40%):

• Cinderella Enchanted (-36%)

• Ariel Iconic (-30%)

• Goliath Enchanted (-39%)

• Spooky Sight Enchanted (-39%)

TOOK A HIT (Lost 40-50%):

• Demona Enchanted (-40%)

• Hades Iconic (-42%)

• Webby Enchanted (-45%)

• Malicious, Mean, and Scary Enchanted (-45%)

• Can't Hold It Back Anymore Enchanted (-47%)

CRASHED (Lost 60%+):

• Shere Khan Legendary (-70%)

• Daisy Duck Legendary (-70%)

• Webby Legendary (-69%)

The Bottom Line

Whispers in the Well rewarded players who focused on competitive staples and punished collectors who bet on IP nostalgia alone. Cinderella and Demona remain the blue-chip investments of the set, backed by tournament play and high transaction volume. The Headless Horseman Legendary is the quiet overperformer that caught everyone by surprise.

If you're cracking packs three months later, you're hoping for Cinderella or an Iconic. Everything else has settled into its natural price floor, and barring a major meta shift, that's where they'll stay until rotation.

The good news? If you missed out early, most of these cards are now 35-50% cheaper than week one. The bad news? If you bought week one thinking prices would go up, well... now you know better for next set.

All prices reflect verified market data as of February 19, 2026. Lorcana is a game of shifting metas, and card prices can change with new set releases, tournament results, or rotation announcements. This guide represents a snapshot in time—your favorite card might spike tomorrow, or crash next week. That's the beauty (and terror) of the secondary market.

Subscribe to stay ahead of the market.